May 22, 2009
Detention for San Diego Union-Tribune employees
Voice of San Diego (one of the paper's chief competitors) reports that Union-Tribune owner Platinum Equity will require all of its employees to sign a contract that bars them from recruiting fellow workers, or those who left the paper within the last six months, to work for a competing outlet.
In exchange for signing the contract, the company promises to give the employees employment.
Given the fact the company is laying off 192 staffers today, U-T employees must be thinking of moving on. But I'm not sure why the paper would want to make those who remain feel trapped by putting a virtual chain on the door.
(VofSD via Romenesko)
Nothing sells like...
Grey talks about porn the way many journalists talk about news. She told the Daily News:
"There's so much free products out there that no one is going to buy adult films anymore unless you make something different, unless you make something exciting and titillating. ... I kind of want to take it back to the beginning of adult films, like a `Deep Throat.'"Deep Throat is something we journalists nostalgic for, too...
LA cops bust on Union-Tribune
Why would LA cops try to meddle with San Diego's newspaper? Because the paper's new owner, Platinum Equity of Beverly Hills, "relies on a $30-million investment from the pension fund of Los Angeles police officers and fire fighters, along with large sums from other public-employee pension systems around the state, to help fund its acquisitions of companies."
From the Los Angeles Times:
As [police union] League President Paul M. Weber views it, that makes the League part owner in the flagging Tribune and League officials are none to happy with the paper’s consistent position that San Diego lawmakers should cut back on salaries and benefits for public employees in order to help close gaping budget deficits.The newspaper's editor was more than a little cool to the idea, and Platinum officials said they won't interfere with the paper's editorial decisions.
"Since the very public employees they continually criticize are now their owners, we strongly believe that those who currently run the editorial pages should be replaced," Weber wrote in a March 26 letter to Platinum CEO Tom Gores.
May 21, 2009
Cuts in St. Paul
From MinnPost.com:
The Strib's Dan Browning, a former PiPress staffer, crunched some numbers and says St. Paul could lose up to 30 newsroom personnel — hard to imagine in a staff that's already skeletal. Would even Dean Singleton's e-edition subscribers pay for a PiPress with 20 percent fewer journalists?
However, Browning's calculation assumes surviving newsroom employees absorb no cuts. A memo from St. Paul's Newspaper Guild indicates management would rather pay everyone less: slashing wages, ending 401(k) matches, eliminating extra pay for night workers, and axing merit pay.
Gang indictments coming in LA*
*Update: The Associated Press reports that 150 members of the predominantly Latino Varrio Hawaiian Gardens street gang have been indicted.
May 20, 2009
Angeles Crest reopens at Vincent Gap
Four in the evening
2. Forget the content, you've gotta get your search words and link pages in order if you want to be popular. Knight Digital Media
3. Google makes Bill Keller's frenemies list. NYO
4. Newspaper vs. the Internet, the cartoon. Slate
Daily News to shutter Valencia printing plant
The meaning of rejection
The spin teams are out today trying to answer those questions for us, but it remains uncertain which arguments will win out. As Dan Schnur of the Jesse M. Unruh Institute of Politics at USC told the Sacramento Bee: "These measures will end up being a $25 million Rorschach test ... Everybody will end up seeing in the results what they want to."
There's no shortage of interesting analysis - in between the predictable sniping from the right and the left. Michael Finnegan at the Los Angeles Times has a smart piece about the dysfunctional relationship between voters and Sacramento. Anthony York at Capitol Weekly thinks the election might mean an end to Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's postpone-the-pain brand of governing. Jerry Roberts and Phil Trounstine argue that Californians must embrace institutional changes before they'll find fiscal stability. Joe Mathews of the New America Foundation proposes more elections to eliminate the need for these high-stakes gambles.
Election results
Carmen Trutanich won the race for Los Angeles City Attorney, beating Jack Weiss 55.7 percent to 44.3 percent. Trutanich took the early lead and never relinquished it.
Barring a Republican miracle, Board of Equalization member Judy Chu will be heading to Congress to replace Labor Secretary Hilda Solis. Chu, a Democrat, won the primary battle for the 32nd Congressional District with 31.9 percent of the vote. State Sen. Gil Cedillo came in second with 23.4 percent and Emanuel Pleitez proved to be a factor with 13.5 percent. Chu will go on to battle Republican Betty Tom Chu in a July 14 runoff, which Judy Chu is expected to win easily.
The race to replace Weiss in LA's 5th City Council district may be too close to call. Paul Koretz is ahead of David Vahedi 50.5 percent to 49.5 percent, but the difference represents only 335 votes.
May 19, 2009
(Not quite the) election results
As for the statewide propositions: All of them are losing, as expected - except for Proposition 1F, as expected. 1F would freeze legislators' salaries in deficit years.
Updated 8:26 p.m.: Carmen Trutanich has a slight lead over Jack Weiss in the race for LA City Attorney. It's 52-48 with about 12 percent of the precincts reporting.
Updated 8:31 p.m.: SGVN is posting updates on the 32nd Congressional District race here.
Updated 8:43 p.m.: In the contest for LA's 5th City Council district, Paul Koretz has a 6 point lead over David Vahedi with about 10 percent of the precincts counted.
Updated 8:49 p.m.: In other news, Marc Ambinder of the Atlantic sent out a tweet saying the California Supreme Court could rule on Proposition 8 - the gay-marriage ban - tomorrow.
Updated 9:56 p.m.: Although ballot counting continues slowly, there has been little movement on the statewide propositions (1A-1E) - they are all losing by wide margins. Meantime, Proposition 1F, which voters see as punitive against lawmakers, is winning easily.
Updated 10:13 p.m.: California voters have resoundingly rejected all five budget propositions (1A-1E) on the ballot, leaving the state government with a $21.3 billion hole to fill. Will recall efforts against the Republican lawmakers who voted for the last budget deal make it easier for Democrats to peel off votes for the next one? Will the state seek federal loan guarantees to keep California's credit line from freezing up? Are Californians ready to revolt - and who would lead the charge?
Update 10:25 p.m.: In the 32nd Congressional District race, Sen. Gil Cedillo has closed the gap on Judy Chu, though he still has a ways to go to catch up. With 31 percent of the precincts now counted, Cedillo has 21 percent of the vote and Chu 32. If Chu holds on, she's almost certain to win the the July 14 runoff against the top Republican vote getter.
Update 10:41 p.m.: Judy Chu 35 - Gil Cedillo 23, with 46 percent of precincts reporting.
Updated 10:46 p.m.: LA City Attorney's race: Carmen Trutanich 52.5 - Jack Weiss 47.5, with 30 percent of precincts reporting.
Updated 11:02 p.m.: Judy Chu 33 - Gil Cedillo 25, with 65 percent of precincts.
Updated 11:04 p.m.: Trutanich 54- Weiss 46, with 43 percent of precincts.
Updated 11:05 p.m.: Going to bed.
Election results Tweets
The Los Angeles County Registrar-Recorder is tweeting at lacountyrrcc.
May 18, 2009
Antelope Valley Press could face class-action lawsuit
Four in the evening
2. The Seattle PostGlobe, run by journalists from the shuttered Seattle Post-Intelligencer, enters its second month of operations - and is asking for donations to make it to its third. Seattle PostGlobe
3. Tell your boss with confidence that daydreaming makes you smarter. The Frontal Cortex
4. Only nine days left to bid on the Huffington Post internship - $15,500 is still the going price. charitybuzz
Singleton interviewed
MediaNews Group owner Dean Singleton on Friday answered a few questions from Michael Roberts at Westword about newspapers and financial turmoil in the industry. For one thing, Singleton said too much of the media coverage concerning papers has been of the sky-is-falling variety, and doesn't fully take into account the unprecedented nature of the economic downturn:I'm still very confident that the newspaper industry will not only survive but will thrive over time. In a bit of a different model, but it still will. And I think the print newspaper will thrive over time. The problems of newspapers, in my view, are very mis-covered by media analysts today. They don't understand the difference between a severe economic downturn, the most severe we've seen in my lifetime, and structural change. There are both going on. There's structural change going on, and it has been for several years, and that will change our business model. But the majority of the revenue declines we're seeing in 2009 are plain, old economic downturn.Asked about a recent memo saying MediaNews might charge for some online content, Singleton said, in part:
If we begin to wean our locally produced content off our free sites, then I think we can drive people to pay for some of that content. It's not going to be a panacea. But we can't continue to give all of our content away for free on the web and expect people to buy it in print and in E-editions. ...Given Singleton's stake in newspapers nationally, and especially here in California, the entire interview (here) well worth reading.
When we look at why people quit buying the newspaper, it's overwhelmingly because "I can get it for free online." So what we need to do is to continue having a very vibrant free site that's full of user-generated copy and information about where to eat and shows that are available and other things. But we need it not to include all of our locally produced news. And that's kind of where we're trying to go.
Final pitch for the 32nd
*If no one wins a majority of the vote tomorrow there will be a runoff in July between the top vote getters in each party. Given the partisan makeup of the district, the top Democrat is expected to win easily.
Four in the morning
2. What can California's political leaders learn from baseball - besides having a better lineup? Arbitration, the hardball way. Calbuzz
3. A judge has ordered the Alton Telegraph to reveal the identities of two people who posted anonymous comments about a murder investigation on the paper's website. St. Louis Post-Dispatch
4. The misconduct that led a trial judge to dismiss charges against Sen. Ted Stevens - namely, the prosecution's failure to turn over key pieces of evidence to the defense - is becoming more common in the American justice system. WaPo
May 17, 2009
Shaky*
The USGS reports a 3.1-magnitude aftershock at about 8:45.
Facebook is lit up.
*Updated: Dan Abendschein at the Pasadena Star-News profiled a Caltech researcher who's trying to determine which tall building in Los Angeles County are at risk of collapse in a major earthquake.
Dowd admits lifting line
May 16, 2009
The service industry
But there's a reason that response feels so wrong. It's because newsrooms are not creating a product - not in the traditional sense. They're providing a service, much in the way doctors and teachers do. If education were a product to be sold, none of us would know a thing about algebra. When doctors "give them what they want" people end up addicted to Oxycontin.
Edward Wasserman at Washington and Lee University helps explain why the temptation to spice up the news to match the consumers' appetite is bad for the news and the consumer:
...for journalists the hitch has always been that news, if done honestly, is routinely unwelcome and, more to the point, that it isn't just another consumer product. It's kind of civic good.Sure, it must be bought, but if success were measured solely by marketability journalists could safely ignore vast areas of coverage that help keep leaders honest and the public conscious of significant realities.
Hence, the paradox: If all you do is give the public what it thinks it wants, you aren't doing your job. But if you ignore those wishes, you won't have a job. ...
I've long argued that news is best understood not as a consumer product, but as a professional service. People buy a paper or go to website not to consume a good, but to renew a relationship with an informant they trust.
That's not to say readers don't want to be amused or don't like reading the comics and hearing about celebrity bust-ups or money-saving recipes. And they aren't passive receptacles: They'll make vigorous use of new media feedback channels to dispute, correct, redirect and enrich the news they get.
But what this suggests is that ultimately, people look to journalists for a special service -- keeping them on top of what they need to know. They can't say exactly what that is, any more than journalists know in the morning what they'll report that day. But they trust the news source to tell them.
Four in the afternoon
2. PBS wants to end the practice of broadcasting religions services on PBS affiliate stations. WaPo
3. New York Times economic reporter Edmund Andrews writes about his personal mortgage meltdown. NYT
4. Google, the Washington Post and the New York Times are making nice - and maybe profits. Neiman Lab
Vu Nguyen, 34
Doctors at Kaiser Permanete Medical Center in Harbor City determined that after a week in a coma, the 34-year-old Long Beach man's brain had stopped functioning.His wife, Heather Hua, and parents, Chuyen and Ngoc Thuy Nguyen, and brother, Viet Nguyen, made the decision about 10 p.m. He died a short time later.
"I love him so much and being his wife and being a part of his life brought me so much happiness," his wife said. "And I thank him for sharing his life with me, even though it was brief."
May 15, 2009
Twitter prank stirs online pot
According to Gawker, someone recycled a Los Angeles Times story from May 2008, when the Supreme Court overturned an earlier ban on gay marriage, and packaged it as new news. Of course, Prop 8 was passed in reaction to the ruling reported on in the May 2008 story.
That fact didn't stop the misinformation flame from spreading. Gawker reports:
But Twitter doesn't sweat the details! Thousands of users "re-Tweeted" it or whatever, and before you know it, the Los Angeles Times' own fucking Twitter feed was sending the gay marriage news out to its 19,700-plus followers.The Times has since Tweeted that the earlier Tweet was not new news. FishbowlLA also issued a correction on its website.
Arizona's oldest paper to fold
The Tucson Citizen will print its final edition on Saturday, as it becomes the latest metropolitan newspaper to shut down operations. The Citizen will transition to an online-only publication, but the site will consist of opinion only. Gannett has yet to set up a budget for the project.From the Citizen:
[Gannett vice president of news Kate] Marymont delivered the news to a staff that has been on hold since March 17, when Gannett said the planned March 21 closing would be postponed due to negotiations with buyers.Stephen Hadland, CEO of the Santa Monica Media Company, which publishes the Culver City Observer, reportedly offered half a million dollars for the Citizen, but was told the he'd have to come up with at least $800,000 and agree to publish a printed edition at least three times a week. Hadland said he has asked the Arizona Attorney General to file a temporary restraining order to keep the paper being published "pending a court order requiring the sale."She said the Citizen's 60 employees would know by the end of the day if they would be laid off, kept on as a short term transition team or be hired long term.
Four in the morning
1. The inaugural edition of the Santa Clarita Valley Independent is out today. SCV Talk columnist Jeff Wilson takes note:It’s been a long time since I felt excitement over a newspaper.(h/t LA Observed)Matter of fact, I don’t remember the last time I felt that way about a newspaper, or more accurately, about the state of the newspaper industry. For years now we’ve gotten used to newspapers downsizing, laying off, even closing all around us, and it’s been downright depressing.
But not today. Today we got a brand new newspaper, and how many communities in America can say that?
2. Census data show a huge decline in Mexican immigration into the United States. New York Times
3. Budgets woes are rattling cages across the state (SJMN). Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger wants to lay off 5,000 workers from the state rolls (SacBee), LAUSD teachers protest over pink slips outside district headquarters (LA Times) and Calbuzz lines up buyers for the coming California state fire sale (Calbuzz).
4. Nieman Lab takes a look at newspaper advertising 2.0 at the New York Times. Neiman Lab
Daily Breeze reporter on life support
Nguyen kicked two goals while playing a soccer game with friends Sunday in a Santa Monica park, and collapsed as he ran with his arms outstretched like an airplane down the field.Friends tried to revive him and summoned paramedics from a nearby fire station. Nguyen, who had shown no signs of ill health, suffered irreversible brain damage. ...
Born in Saigon, Vietnam, on Feb. 20, 1975, Nguyen was 2 months old when his father, attack pilot Chuyen Nguyen, and mother, Ngoc Thuy Nguyen, were among the first refugees to escape and come to the United States.
Raised in Garden Grove, Nguyen decided early on he wanted to be a reporter. An editor at Rancho Alamitos High School in Garden Grove, he went to work as a reporter for the Seattle Times, Orange County Register, Nguoi Viet 2 in Westminster, and The Associated Press in Springfield, Ill.
May 14, 2009
Information warehouse
From the Economist:
If the model is true, then we'd be seeing depressed wages (check), cheaper production values (check), increased outsourcing (check), less local control despite calls for more (check), a push to lower quality and standards (check), and mass consolidation, bankruptcies and layoffs (check, check, check).The main victim of this trend is not so much the newspaper (although it is certainly declining) as the conventional news package. Open almost any leading metropolitan newspaper, or look at its website, and you will find the same things. There will be a mixture of local, national, international, business and sports news. There will be weather forecasts. There will be display and classified advertisements. There will be leaders, letters from readers, and probably a crossword.
This package, which was emulated first by broadcasters and then by internet pioneers such as AOL.com and MSN.com, works rather like an old-fashioned department store. It provides a fair selection of useful information of dependable quality in a single place. And the fate of the news package is similar to that of the department store. Some customers have been lured away by discount chains; others have been drawn to boutiques.
The Wal-Marts of the news world are online portals like Yahoo! and Google News, which collect tens of thousands of stories. Some are licensed from wire services like Reuters and the Associated Press. But most consist simply of a headline, a sentence and a link to a newspaper or television website where the full story can be read. The aggregators make money by funnelling readers past advertisements, which may be tailored to their presumed interests. They are cheap to run: Google News does not even employ an editor.
Four in the morning
2. Rep. Linda Sanchez, D-Lakewood, had a baby. LAT
3. "No one manipulates the press like David Geffen," writes Mark Lacter at LA Biz Observed. *New York Post story calls talks between Geffen and the New York Times "guff".
4. Evan George of the Los Angeles Daily Journal dug through public records and found that a state program set up to reimburse patients who were wrongly dumped by their private health insurers has been largely ineffective. The story is behind a paywall, but here's an excerpt:
A year after Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's administration unveiled a series of landmark legal settlements intended to relieve thousands of Californians who had their health insurance revoked, only a fraction of patients have taken part in the program, and just four are known to have received any kind of payment from their insurer, a Daily Journal investigation has found.
Overall, just 5 percent of patients wanted or were aware of the state's plan and took part in it, records show. Many of those who lost their insurance racked up crippling debt for medical costs when their policies were rescinded.
-snip-
A Department of Managed Health Care spokeswoman defended the program this month, saying it had won new health coverage for 177 Californians who otherwise would have stayed uninsured. "We were able to provide that for them in a quick way where they wouldn't have to go through a lengthy court battle," spokeswoman Lynne Randolph said.
Asked why medical bills have not been addressed, Randolph blamed the delay on private lawyers and the Los Angeles city attorney, whose ongoing lawsuits have interfered with the state's settlement notices.
Is the auto mall going extinct?*
But the economic downturn has sucked the life out of many big box stores, and sent a few into bankruptcy. But worse for cities is the loss of dealerships, which generate the sales tax needed to keep city services going. So the news out today that ailing GM and bankrupt Chrysler will eliminate hundreds more dealerships is staggering.
Chrysler told a bankruptcy court it plans to close 789 dealerships nationwide; GM is expected to close as many as 2,600. Already California has lost 145 dealerships and it's not clear exactly how many more will go. The LA Times reports:
Throughout the state, local governments are struggling to keep their auto dealerships alive, because most have become reliant on the big-ticket sellers to provide a steady stream of sales tax income.*Update: Three San Fernando Valley dealerships are on the chopping block, the Daily News reports.
Since Proposition 13 limited California property taxes in 1978, many cities have encouraged the construction of malls and other retail uses that bring in sales taxes to fund the municipal budget.
Car dealerships are now among the biggest generators of tax revenue.
May 13, 2009
North Korea to try jailed journalists
A different kind of pay wall
Huffington Post, which already doesn't pay its writers, is auctioning off an "eye opening" internship in New York or Washington. So far the top bid is $13,000. From Silicon Alley Insider:
The auction's beneficiary, The Robert F. Kennedy Center for Justice and Human Rights, seems exceptionally worthy. But are unemployed media wannabes really this worthless?The bidding is in $2,500 increments, so you only need to scrape together $15,500 to get in the job. Hurry up! Only 14 days left!If the top bidder lives in Connecticut, the winner even has to pay sales tax on the internship.
If anyone was going to auction off an internship, though, it would be Arianna Huffington's Huffington Post, which features tons of content generated free by bloggers and celebrities just happy to have a platform. HuffPo did recently start a fund to employ some laid-off investigative reporters, but the company thrives primarily on "citizen" journalism and news that other outlets spend money reporting.
(h/t Bloggasm)
Compromised in Washington State
In lobbying aggressively for the tax break, the publishers sacrificed their moral authority to challenge favoritism, fiscal imprudence and self-dealing on the part of the state government and the dozens of political figures who supported the measure. ...Mutter estimates that no more than 15 reporter jobs would be saved if every dime went to paper payrolls.
:: Will the paper fairly cover upcoming political campaigns involving the politicians who supported the tax break?
:: Will future political endorsements be tilted in favor of the politicians who helped the newspapers?
Civil charges likely for Mozilo
Gabe Friedman of the Los Angeles Daily Journal first reported back in March that SEC staff was pursuing civil charges against Mozilo and at least two other company executives.
Goodbye, Daily News; farewell, Union-Tribune
Former Daily News editor Ron Kaye remembers without an ounce of fondness the man who fired him, Ed Moss. Yesterday Moss announced he was resigning his post as publisher of the Daily News and president of LANG to take over as publisher of the San Diego Union-Tribune. Kaye writes:Sending Moss to fix a struggling paper is like sending a mortician to treat an ailing patient. He will do the only thing he knows how to do: Cut, and cut, and cut some more: When he's done with his handiwork, the U-T will be ready for embalming and burial much like the Daily News is. ...*The Union-Tribune has published a short bio on Ed Moss.
In his 23 months at the Daily News, the editorial staff -- already reduced by half in previous years -- was slashed by two-thirds. There's now only nine news reporters and a staff of barely 40 to produce the paper which has shrunk to the point most days that it gives new meaning to the idea of a fast-read newspaper.
Almost every department of the paper from circulation to sales has been eliminated or gutted to the point of dysfunction. ...
My heart goes out to my colleagues still at the Daily News every time I pick up the paper and see what Moss' leadership has done to it. Somehow I hope it will be different in San Diego but I doubt it.
May 12, 2009
Hamilton named LANG president
In addition, Liz Gaier, who served for a time as publisher of the Daily Breeze, will take over as interim publisher of the Los Angeles Daily News.
The company memo follows:
Los Angeles Newspaper Group (LANG) today announced the promotion of Fred Hamilton to President. Hamilton, previously President and Publisher of the Inland Division of LANG, replaces Ed Moss, who resigned to become Publisher of the San Diego Union Tribune. Hamilton brings more than 25 years of experience in the newspaper industry to this position, having previously served as publisher of several newspapers in the Western United Sates prior to joining the Los Angeles Newspaper Group.*Update: The Union-Tribune gathers Moss.
“Ed Moss did a terrific job for us as head of LANG, and we are sorry to see him go,” said Steve Rossi, President and CEO of California Newspapers Partnership, of which LANG is a part. “However, we are fortunate that Fred Hamilton is ideally suited and prepared for the top Position in LANG.”
In addition, Liz Gaier, MediaNews Group’s Senior Vice President of Business Development, was named interim Publisher of the Los Angeles Daily News. In addition to her corporate experience, Liz has considerable experience in newspaper operations, including a recent assignment as Publisher of the Torrance Daily Breeze.
MediaNews memo outlines new online strategy*
MediaNews Group execs Dean Singleton and Jody Lodovic sent out a memo Friday that says the chain will end the practice of giving readers free access to its newspaper websites. They leave it up in the air whether readers will have to pay a subscription fee or simply register to gain access.The plan also calls for overhauling the chain's websites so that they look less like the print edition and provide more regional and youth-oriented content - which seems to be an extension of the consolidation that's already occurred within LANG, BANG, etc.
Here's the problem as Singleton and Lodovic see it:
First, we continue to do an injustice to our print subscribers and create perceptions that our content has no value by putting all of our print content online for free. Not only does this erode our print circulation, it devalues the core of our business - the great local journalism we (and only we) produce on a daily basis. Second, our interactive revenue growth has slowed because it has been too closely tied to our print classified business, which has suffered with the advent of Craigslist and other free online classified opportunities. Finally, we are not significantly extending the reach of our audience, as our online products too closely resemble the newspaper, and thus fail to meaningfully reach the next generation of readers.Here's what they propose to do about it:
We will begin to move away from putting all of our newspaper content online for free. Instead, we will explore a variety of premium offerings that apply real value to our print content. We are not trying to invent new premium products, but instead tell our existing print readers that what they are buying has real value, and to our online audience (who don't buy the print edition), that if you want access to all online content, you are going to have to register, and/or pay. If a non-subscriber wants the newspaper content in its entirety online, they will be directed to some sort of registration or pay vehicle (and if they are a print subscriber, they will have full access at no charge).Click here to read the full memo.
-snip-
We will begin differentiating our sites from the newspaper and focus on strategies designed to reach younger audiences and extend our reach. The websites, newspaper.com as we call them now, will become a different product. This new site, which we have been calling news.com, will be a regional news site that is actively managed to present breaking news. It will continue to draw a content from the newspaper (but probably in a more abbreviated form), but will also have user-generated content, community involvement and third party content.
*In somewhat related news, the Los Angeles Daily News is inviting readers to follow the paper on Twitter.
May 11, 2009
The electronic Times
The New York Times has added a couple new ways to read the paper online.The first is Times Wire, which provides real-time updates of everything posted to the website. To keep readers from getting overwhelmed, the feed has a "your news" option that lets them include only those sections they want to hear from.
The Times has also launched Times Reader 2.0, a subscription service that's built on Adobe Air to create a more newspaper-ish experience when reading online. Dan Kennedy at Media Nation had this to say:
Times Reader really does offer a superior online reading experience. You're more likely actually to read the paper rather than just skip around. And it's a lot cheaper (we get the Sunday print edition delivered, so there's no extra charge for us) — not to mention more environmentally friendly — than the print edition.Kennedy also said this:
But free is free. In addition, the Times Web edition is a livelier place, with more ads (perhaps that will change as Times Reader gains in acceptance), blogs and other extra content. In addition, if you're a blogger and you want to post something you see in Times Reader, you have to leave, access the Web edition and find the story again in order to grab the URL.The Times Reader costs $3.45 a week.
There's more on the Times e-reader R&D shop at the Nieman Lab.
(h/ts LA Observed and Media Nation)
Another industry gets nervous
Hulu illustrates the quandary that media executives face as they weigh the potential of the Internet against their dependable, old-line businesses. If the television industry does not find a way to preserve its two pillars of revenue -- advertising and subscription fees -- the consequences could be dire. Analysts point to the rapid deterioration of newspapers, which traded paying print subscribers for the expectation of big bucks from online advertising that have not materialized.Hulu counted 42 million viewers in March and Disney just decided to start putting shows on the site.
Fact-based voting
Sanchez out at the Daily News*
Yes, George Sanchez, steward and bargaining team member, has been laid off from the Daily News. The cited reason was economic need, George was the least senior of two LAUSD reporters. Friday was George's last day of work.Daily News Editor Carolina Garcia hired Sanchez last fall to replace education reporter Naush Boghossian, who left the paper for a PR job last May.
Reporter Connie Llanos will continue to cover education for Daily News.
*Updated: I've heard from a couple people that management was looking to eliminate someone from the Metro desk and that Sanchez volunteered to take the bullet. With his departure, the desk is down to 9 reporters, plus columnist Dennis McCarthy.
Saberi freed*
*Update: Alan Mutter offered this sobering reminder:
As we celebrate the liberation of journalist Roxana Saberi from prison in Iran, don’t forget that two other innocent American newswomen are being held on similarly trumped-up charges in North Korea.
Laura Ling and Euna Lee, two correspondents for San Francisco-based Current TV, have been detained in North Korea since March 17, when they were arrested while filming a story at the border between China and North Korea.
May 10, 2009
Anti-anti-SLAPP legislation in Sacramento
The legislation would bar government agencies from seeking repayment of attorney fees under the state's anti-SLAPP law when they are sued to produce public documents or to comply with public meeting requirements. Anti-SLAPP allows defendants to collect attorney fees when a court decides a case is without merit.
McKee and CalAware joined a lawsuit brought against Orange Unified School District for alleged violations of public meeting law. They lost the case and the court awarded the district more than $80,000 in attorney fees.
The view from above
Maureen Dowd (who'd written about the industry's decadence last month) used "Star Trek" as a trope to illustrate the troubles for newspapers. Frank Rich's Sunday column got more directly to the point, under the cheery title: "The American Press on Suicide Watch."
Indeed, Rich grabbed hold of what seems to me to be the central argument against placing our faith in technology to create Journalism 2.0 - namely, that there is no widget to get us around the strictures of capitalism. As Rich writes:
What can’t be reinvented is the wheel of commerce. Just because information wants to be free on the Internet doesn’t mean it can always be free. Web advertising will never be profitable enough to support ambitious news gathering. If a public that thinks nothing of spending money on texting or pornography doesn’t foot the bill for such reportage, it won’t happen.(Of course, not everyone thinks professional journalism need continue. I'm too cranky right now to address that silliness.)
Rich and others look to the past and see a precedence for for-profit journalism:
It’s all a matter of priorities. Not long ago, we laughed at the idea of pay TV. Free television was considered an inalienable American right (as long as it was paid for by advertisers). Then cable and satellite became the national standard.True. But journalism isn't cable or satellite, it's a few channels on a cable or satellite system. Already people pay a subscription of sorts to have Internet access, but the system doesn't kick anything down to the content providers.
Rich goes off the rails, however, when he casually asserts that some journalism (read, the local stuff papers like the New York Times don't cover) will be taken care of by "voluntary 'citizen journalists' with time on their hands, integrity and a Web site."
That kind of inverted pyramid - big paper journalism continuing to get funds while the local and regional stuff gets taken care of for free - cannot be sustained. Where does Rich think journalists will gain the "technical expertise" to ferret out "what is happening behind closed doors at corrupt, hard-to-penetrate institutions in Washington or Wall Street" if not at smaller newspapers/news organizations? And what about the closed doors at City Hall or the school district? Are they suddenly easier to open? Are the standards for ferreting out the corruption outside of Washington and New York not as important?
If we're going down, we're going down together. Locking yourself in the captain's quarters won't save you when the ship begins to sink.
Chronicle layoffs
May 8, 2009
Who's coming to dinner*
Fox News has Todd Palin. The Houston Chronicle has Alberto Gonzalez. CNN has Ashton Kutcher and Janet Napolitano. Sully Sullenberger chose to dine with the New York Daily News and George Lucas chose Fortune. ABC News has David Axelrod and Meghan McCain, among others, and the NBC News tables will include Samuel L. Jackson, William H. Macy, and Mike Myers.
Read the complete list of invitees to tomorrow's White House Correspondents Dinner here.
*Updated: Frank Davies at the Mercury News had a story about the tarting up of the correspondents dinner:
"It used to be a rock star at this dinner was the White House chief of staff, not Steve Tyler of Aerosmith," said Carol Joynt, a former TV producer who chronicles Washington society.
She has attended two dozen dinners and seen them evolve from low-key events where reporters chatted up government sources to a series of "circus acts," with strange juxtapositions of power and fluff. "It's become just a mashed-up free-for-all," Joynt said.
MediaNews plunked down $4,000 for a table. The guest of honor was Carol Williams, White House director of media affairs.
Crystal balls are notoriously unreliable
The good news was that the event, titled “What Comes After Newspapers?,” really didn’t waste a lot of time asking, “How do we save newspapers?” but largely accepted that their day is ending. You might think this is obvious, but too many of these gatherings today are still stuck in rescue mode.Newspapers might die off. Then again, they might not. If you're invested in their extinction, then I guess I can understand the psychology of planning their wake. If you just want people to take the threat of extinction more seriously - or to take alternative ways of presenting news more seriously - there are better arguments to make. Best of all, show us the plan that takes us beyond newspapers and avoid the argument altogether.
California investigated*
Targeting regional and statewide journalism offers a solution to the crisis in journalism. The project will serve as a watchdog for government and powerful institutions, fulfilling the core mandate of CIR. It will partner with existing news organizations, journalism schools and other institutions to develop innovative ways to inform and engage Californians on issues that affect them in their communities and in their daily lives.The release also includes a link to a "job descriptions" page.
*Correction: Perhaps due to wishful thinking, I'd mistakenly typed "$2.4 billion in grant funds." It's $2.4 million.
May 7, 2009
Four at night
By all means, let's keep the citizens in citizen journalism. Let any interested reader find the raw data from hundreds of localities if they wish. But the measure of our success should be the perspective and understanding we provided for our readers, not how much data was accumulated by how many people or how much of it reverberated elsewhere in the national news echo chamber.Huffington Post
2. Ken Doctor at Content Bridges considers the algorithms of the new Google News:
As print shrinks, Google will replace its daily functionality, its daily utility -- and it's been on that road for awhile -- with Google News, v2. It sounds like Google News, v1 meets Google IG meets AdWords for news, a new algorithm that knows us better than we know ourselves. Importantly ... Google is recognizing how fundamentally lazy we all are. In effect, we're taken to be the corpulent creatures in Wall E. Google seems to be saying: you don't have to do anything, we'll be your new paperboy.Content Bridges
3. Jason Pontin at Technology Review proposes ways to save print journalism - starting with an assessment of print journalism's true value:
The comparative advantage of mainstream media is not the ownership of presses, but the collaboration of professionals. The creation of good journalism is a tremendously laborious process, requiring an infrastructure more expensive than any press. The illustration and design of stories has an infrastructure, too. Developing an audience that will attract particular advertisers requires another infrastructure. Selling advertising requires yet another. These structures, which allow publications to reach large, coherent audiences, can exist only within complex organizations, mostly businesses.Technology Review via Newspaper Death Watch
4. Rob Fishman at Huffington Post reports on the words war between David Carr of the New York Times and Michael Wolff of Newser, and analyzes where they're getting their ammunition:
It's hip for bloggers to bite the hand that feeds them, and Wolff's got some oral fixation. It's not good enough for him to kick the Boston Globe or Seattle Post-Intelligencer while they're down; he needs to cite their own articles while he's doing it. We all have a personal stake in The New York Times, but for Wolff it's more than that, it's his bread and butter. Without the news, he's just an -er.Huffington Post
Gawkward
To hell with that, Tate writes, because while he covered restaurants and hotels in the East Bay he met a few bloggers in Oakland who covered meetings with deep, obsessive concern:
...as a newspaper reporter who spent a few years covering a town much like Baltimore — Oakland, California — I often found that bloggers were the only other writers in the room at certain city council committee meetings and at certain community events. They tended to be the sort of persistently-involved residents newspapermen often refer to as "gadflies" — deeply, obsessively concerned about issues large and infinitesimal in the communities where they lived...They may be doing fine, important work, but they're not doing just what Simon suggests. If they devote themselves to a beat and follow certain standards (like not getting deeply, obsessively involved in the issues they cover), then, they'll be doing what Simon suggests. If they fan out across the country and cover big towns and small (not just Baltimore and Oakland), submit their work to editorial oversight and to strive for accuracy, fairness and accountability, they'll be doing what Simon suggests. And if they do, it's likely they'll want to get paid for the work.
Collectively, these bloggers are doing just what Simon suggests: attending meetings, developing sources and holding government accountable every day.
Tate singles out the work of Echa Schneider, who blogs at ABetterOakland.com, and points to a column in the San Francisco Chronicle as proof of her bona fides. She, however, seems less inclined to see herself as a replacement for professional journalism. From the Chronicle column:
When I called her Wednesday, [Schneider] reluctantly accepted a compliment as the city's No. 1 blog site, then complained about Oakland's lack of news coverage...
Massive layoffs at the Union-Tribune
The layoffs represent about 18 percent of the total workforce and will cut across all departments - there is no breakdown for how many newsroom staffers will be lost. About 850 employees will remain once the layoffs are completed.
The Union-Tribune story about the cuts notes that the paper just won a fourth Pulitzer Prize this year, for editorial cartoonist Steve Breen.
(Union-Tribune via Romenesko)
Journalism on the Hill
50 > 13
The big story today for the L.A. Dodgers was supposed to be that the club had set the Major League record for consecutive home-game wins (13-0) at the start of a season, beating the previous record of 12 consecutive wins set by the 1911 Detroit Tigers.But the Los Angeles Times just broke the news that star player Manny Ramirez will be suspended for 50 games after testing positive for performance enhancing drugs.
I guess 13 really is an unlucky number.
*Update: Ramirez blamed the positive test on a medication prescribed to him by a doctor.
May 6, 2009
Globe shutdown averted, Senate hearing goes on
Meantime, Massachusetts Sen. John Kerry has scheduled a hearing for today at 11:30 a.m. PST to discuss the future of journalism in light of the turmoil at the Globe and elsewhere. As has become obligatory, the panel will include a representative from Google and Huffington Post co-founder Arianna Huffington.
Also slated to speak are David Simon, creator of "The Wire" and former Baltimore Sun reporter; Steve Coll, president of the New America Foundation and former managing editor of the Washington Post; Dallas Morning News Publisher James Moroney, and Alberto Ibargüen, president and CEO of the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation.
May 5, 2009
Four in the morning
2. Platinum Equity of Beverly Hills has completed its purchase of the San Diego Union-Tribune and has appointed Paul Bridwell, "an experienced turnaround specialist," to restructure the newspaper. U-T
3. The Los Angeles Times also hires people. Shane Goldmacher, the 25-year-old political blogger behind the Sacramento Bee's Capitol Alert, will move to the Times Sacramento bureau in June. Capitol Alert via LA Observed
4. Even The Onion is having financial trouble. fishbowlLA
May 4, 2009
Trying to recall
The internecine battle is rooted in Adams' vote for a budget bill in February that included taxes. Former GOP chairman Mike Schroeder and Atlas PAC head L
"The petition you hold is the creation of two very wealthy Orange County men who care less about our community and more about their own political ambitions. They want us to pay $900,000 in our hard earned tax dollars to pay for another election and their partisan political games...because Adams stood with taxpayers and working families and against their reckless agenda."(That's Mountjoy up top, Adams below)
Step inside the way-back machine
The video is more evidence that newspapers, for all their faults, didn't miss the significance of going online, they misunderstood (as most of us did) how the Internet would alter the economic landscape. Consider the assessment David Cole offers for what the electronic newspaper would mean for the Chronicle: "We're not in it to make money" he says, adding "we're probably not going to lose a lot."
Exactly the wrong instincts on both points.
(*Also in 1981: Ronald Reagan became president, Rupert Murdoch bought the Times of London, MTV was launched)
Four in the afternoon
2. Huffington Post founder and LRC co-host Arianna Huffington will receive a lifetime achievement award in journalism from the Newhouse School of Public Communications at Syracuse University. Gawker
3. The New York Times Co. plays a 60-day game of chicken with the Boston Globe. NYT
4. The New York Times guild is expected to approve a 5-percent pay cut, but expects layoffs anyway. NYO
Krugman: Wage cuts could lead to unemployment
Krugman writes:
Here’s how the paradox works. Suppose that workers at the XYZ Corporation accept a pay cut. That lets XYZ management cut prices, making its products more competitive. Sales rise, and more workers can keep their jobs. So you might think that wage cuts raise employment — which they do at the level of the individual employer.My question, does this argument hold true for individual sectors in the economy... say, newspapers? If every major newspaper publisher cuts wages, does that negate the benefit to individual companies?But if everyone takes a pay cut, nobody gains a competitive advantage. So there’s no benefit to the economy from lower wages. Meanwhile, the fall in wages can worsen the economy’s problems on other fronts.
Turn that frown upside down
April 30, 2009The piece, if you can follow it, goes on to quote a few examples of winning thinking, all of which you can read here.
THINK PIECE: WHINE OR WIN— REDEFINE THE INDUSTRY, YOU'RE EITHER IN OR NOT
Constantly hearing the doom and gloom...the cutbacks, the negative stuff. It's pretty real, but throughout our company there's a LOT of re-invention going on. In fact, when this economy improves, WE will be the ones with the upper hand because instead of dwelling on the pain, we're doing something about it. Economically of course, AND IN CONTENT/CREATIVE. As sad as the state of the economy is, it's equally sad to see people whining, complaining and feeling sorry for themselves and the industry, when that energy can go toward breaking down some walls.
Supreme Court still disturbed by 2004 nipple sighting
Last year, the appeals court threw out the fine against CBS, saying the FCC strayed from its long-held approach of applying identical standards to words and images when reviewing complaints of indecency.Last week the Supreme Court ruled the FCC has the right to impose hefty fines to keep the public airwaves clean.
The appellate court said the incident lasted nine-sixteenths of one second and should have been regarded as ''fleeting.'' The FCC previously deviated from its nearly 30-year practice of fining indecent broadcast programming only when it was so ''pervasive as to amount to 'shock treatment' for the audience,'' the court said.
May 3, 2009
From the local blogs
Watershed News continues to track the progress of Nicholas Rice, the Hermosa Beach climber attempting to summit Manaslu in the Nepalese Himalaya. Rice recently assisted two exhausted climbers down from the mountain. One later died, the other recovered. Rice plans to make a summit attempt Tuesday. Watershed News
ShopEatSleep got invited to "brinner" at Le Grande Orange in Pasadena. ShopEatSleep
May 2, 2009
Broken ladders
Some journalists strove for the highest echelons - the New York Times, Washington Post, Wall Street Journal. Others found contentment - or a ceiling - on lower rungs.
And so it went for decades - the system established a common work ethic and continuity of purpose (some would argue it also weakened journalism by encouraging conformity and self-promotion).
Recently, the well-worn rungs of the ladder have begun to break, stranding hundreds of talented journalists in a kind of limbo.
From "The Media's Lost Generation" in Slate:
As the chance to move up diminishes, the industry freezes and starts to fragment. Small newspapers suffer as ambition heads elsewhere and larger papers suffer because their talent pool isn't refreshed. And not only do talented people stop moving through the system, but so do the ideals and ideas they used to carry with them - the work ethic, the standards, the institutional memory and the sense of common purpose.Like many industries, the mainstream media—newspaper and magazine companies in particular—have been ravaged by the recession and the infringing Internet over the last six months. Professional viability in this brave new world has become akin to winning a high-stakes game of musical chairs. The media business has always been a deeply competitive bastion of ambition; yet today's journalists—including both those sidelined by layoffs and those still clinging desperately their workplace desks—have been left to wonder whether the very idea of ambition makes sense anymore.
"How do you progress in an industry that has no clear path to anywhere?" asked Glynnis MacNicol, a media analyst and editor of FishbowlNY. "Right now, the definition of success in the media is not to be unemployed."
Already, the traditions of the profession are beginning to show strain as people who never attempted to climb the old ladder try to build new ones. Once again, from Slate:
"When I went to school, it was about, 'Afflict the comfortable and comfort the afflicted,' " says Michael Caruso, a former editor at the Village Voice, Vanity Fair, Details, and many other magazines. "You wanted to keep the government honest. Today the goals are different. It's mostly about self-expression."That's an oversimplification, but the cynicism illustrates a real fear that the best, tested ideals of journalism might not survive if the system that created them falls apart.
Citizen scientists
“Part of it is a misrepresentation of qualifications,” Lipson told me in a phone conversation. “They started putting the word ‘Dr’ in front of everyone’s name — more or less for anyone who has a doctorate in something or other — and Patricia Fitzgerald claims to have a doctorate in homeopathy, whatever that is. Homeopathy is a completely discredited fantasy. When you give that kind of credibility — I mean first you invite them to a well-known mainstream outlet, you let them call themselves a doctor when they’re not really qualified, and then you let them interview other people and present them as professionals — it just layers on and layers on.”
It would be different if they admitted up front that these stories were all editorial in nature, the internist said, and presented them as such. He compared the method of fact checking in the health section of HuffPo to that of the Gray Lady. “They need to exercise some kind of journalistic integrity,” Lipson said. “When you read the New York Times, whether you agree with what they do or not — people can argue about the quality having gone down — but when you read the editorial pages and you read the news, you know there’s some editing going on. You know they don’t just say, ‘write whatever you want and we’ll throw our name above it.’ They have real editors.”
Four in the afternoon
2. The Los Angeles Daily News laid off Dodgers beat writer Tony Jackson. LAO
3. Washington Times columnist and sometimes Drudge Report editor Andrew Breitbart spoke at an anti-tax rally in front of Pasadena City Hall and said this about how America treats dissenters: "Just like in Cuba, like in Venezuela, those that dissent are marginalized at best, and jailed or killed or worse." PSN
4. Charlie Munger, who has a big stake in the Los Angeles Daily Journal, had this to say about the state of the newspaper industry: "It’s really a national tragedy. As they disappear - I think what replaces them won’t be as desirable as what we’re losing." His partner, Warren Buffett, said he wouldn't buy another newspaper "at any price." PaidContent
Snapshot
May 1, 2009
Layoffs come at a furious pace
Buyouts and wage cuts in Syracuse
Editor and Publisher Stephen A. Rogers, who announced the measures in staff meetings, offered a buyout of a year's pay to employees with at least seven years of full-time experience. For all remaining employees, pay will be reduced July 1 through the end of the year by a range of 5 to 12 percent, depending on pay levels. Highest-salaried people will get the steepest cuts. In addition, all employees will begin to contribute 25 percent of their health care coverage costs.
The cuts come on the heels of 10 days of involuntary furlough announced last month.
Apr 30, 2009
Contraction
Justice Souter to retire
California's tireless Attorney General
Two departures at the Daily Journal
Also leaving, Superior Court reporter Cortney Fielding, who decided she'd be better off striking out on her own. Fielding, who went to the DJ in January 2008 from the Pasadena Star-News, plans to freelance for now. From her parting email:
...leaving was a tough decision. I’ve loved working with everyone here and really enjoy covering LA courts, but curiosity has gotten the better of me. I want to see what, if anything, I can accomplish out on my own and maybe catch my breath a little while figuring out what I want to do next in this business.The rest of the email is here.
Granted, this is something I probably couldn’t do if I hadn’t had the foresight to marry a man who would one day collect a stable paycheck from a boring old insurance company, so props go to me for that.
I got into journalism because I enjoyed storytelling and lacked the imagination necessary to make stories up myself. Why bother when there is already so much great material ripe for the picking? I plan on continuing to tell other people’s stories. I’ve gotten a few cool freelance gigs to get me started, and I’m working on some bigger projects I’ll tell everyone about after they are more certain-so I don’t look like a total loser if they fall through.
But, if by the end of the year, I’m calling you as a PR person trying to pitch a story about an amazing law firm’s ground-breaking swine-flu practice, I guess we will know this was a very,very bad idea.