Showing posts with label fast food. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fast food. Show all posts

Dec 29, 2010

Patch, Patch, Patch

AOL's Patch network hit 750 today - that's 750 individual Patch sites now running across the country. It's up from 500 in early December and up from 30 at the start of the year. I'm told the rapid roll out earned some top managers their holiday bonuses, and that some Patchers worried quality could suffer in the furious effort to meet the goal.

At least AOL realized that the mini-plagiarism outbreak needed a response. A reliable source tells me Patch editors will get mandatory plagiarism-prevention training.

And since I've gotten into a one-way argument with the LA Weekly over all this, here's another thought:

While the Weekly likes to describe Patch as the WalMart of news, I think it risks becoming like a fast-food chain - each franchise operated locally but serving a narrow menu of nearly identical content and dictated to by national headquarters. Think of AOL as the McDonald's Corp. of information and each Patch site as a local joint. Different kids in the play yard, but every Happy Meal the same.

Now, AOL's stated goal is to let individual editors cater to their local communities using only a common platform. Editors are expected to tailor content to local readers, not follow a single AOL formula; and if AOL can resist top-down meddling, and encourage bottom-up innovation, then the network might avoid the fast-food stamp.

But AOL will inevitably count hits and ad dollars and wonder why some site are doing better than others. Being the conglomerate that it is, AOL will think conformity is the best prescription for uneven performance. When controversy strikes - lawsuits, boycotts, plagiarism, etc. - AOL will be tempted to craft one-size-fits-all edicts that will, over time, narrow the menu to the things that work best - i.e., draw the most traffic at the lowest cost.

Of course, news stories aren't Happy Meals and different cities will always have different issues to cover. The best editors at the best Patch sites will resist the mothership. But I haven't seen a newspaper chain yet that hasn't consolidated and embraced sameness as a way to cuts costs in tough times. If Patch can buck the trend, that would be something special.

Oct 5, 2009

Little news

Newsweek chronicles the "hyperlocal" movement's attempts to gain a foothold in three New Jersey suburbs. It appears that even though the business model has yet to pay off that the homegrown efforts started by local journalists already are being supplanted by sites owned by national media giants - the New York Times, AOL and MSNBC among them. Why would the majors want to play in the minor leagues? From Newsweek
[I]f an operation like AOL's Patch can link together a network of $200,000-a-year sites each run by a single reporter, and then amortize big expenses (like technology and ad sales) across multiple sites, you could start to see decent profits. The low overhead is crucial: not only are startups like Patch using less costly labor, but they also believe readership and revenue will grow as networks of hyperlocal blogs link to each other, and as they become adept at persuading small businesses that never advertised in newspapers to give online advertising a shot—a key to Patch's strategy.
This model would probably only work in heavily populated suburbs. But it does seem logical that the chain websites would end up chasing revenue from the other types of chains that grow up in suburban landscapes: Starbucks, Ruby Tuesdays, Barnes and Noble, and the like. That, in turn, is likely going to shape how these sites develop.

Sep 30, 2009

Faster, cheaper, less nutritious

I've often wondered if the newsroom of the future would look more like a fast-food joint than the big newspaper newsrooms we see today.

Instead of delivering news to the doorstep like the erstwhile milk man did, news will be delivered through websites on the information superhighway. This means people will be looking for a convenient place to stop to get some news quick before getting back on the road. Whether on their office computer, their cell phone or their laptop at home, they will be looking for predictable markers to find the site, predictable menu items to peruse and a predictable time line for how long it takes to get and then consume what they came for.

People might even pay for this predictability.

If the virtual world shapes up like the real one has, this would probably mean more networked wire services churning out easily digestible stories packaged together by local crews but using fewer local ingredients.

This type of format for online news seems inevitable - it's how we consume things. The San Diego News Network seems to be headed in that direction, with its Starbucks business plan. So does MediaNews Group, which has individual newspapers that use similar online templates and route copy through centralized desks so it can be shared by the group. Other chains will either sell or follow suit.

It doesn't mean all higher-end offerings will be crowded out - SDNN isn't going to kill the New Yorker anymore than McDonalds killed Tavern on the Green*. There will still be readers who want to savor the news. Also, news content cannot be completely divorced from geography since people still care about local sports teams, local schools and local businesses. Still, I think we can expect more conformity than differentiation on the web in the coming decade. Conformity is easier to capitalize upon.

If the cookie-cutter approach goes too far it might invite a welcome backlash, just as industrial farming and fast-food restaurants brought us farmer's markets and the organic movement. Let's also hope quality alternative and local media find good real estate along the highway.

*Updated 10/1: An imperfect comparison at best, it turns out. As a reader pointed out, Tavern on the Green filed for bankruptcy in September. I doubt McDonalds was to blame and the point still holds up - hell, with the way bankruptcies have hit newspaper companies, maybe it's even closer to the truth.

Jan 18, 2008

Convergence: The Little Engine that I could give a shit about

“I don’t want to hire single platform journalists anymore.”
That bold statement came from Paul Horrocks, editor of the Manchester Evening News in the UK.

Anyone inspired by a comment like that belongs in accounting, not in journalism. Still, convergence will probably work for the same reason that traffic accidents draw rubberneckers. The new journalism is about reaping the grazers, bored people in their homes or offices who just want a little distraction in their day.

Having reporters put lots of soundbites, photos and and quick links together with a short story will sell for the same reason that McDonald's hamburgers sell. And the content will usually be as healthy for the mind as that fast food is for the body.