Showing posts with label dumb. Show all posts
Showing posts with label dumb. Show all posts

Jan 18, 2008

Why let reporters get in the way of good journalism?

Citizen journalism is all the rage with cost-cutting news outfits. After all, getting someone to spout off for free is highly efficient.

But those cynical skeptics at Mother Jones just can't keep their critical mouths shut about the potential downside.

Here's an excerpt:

The wave of journalistic outsourcing has some new-media advocates hailing the death of the "fortress newsroom" mentality and touting the beginning of an era where newspapers not only listen to their readers but invite them into the inner sanctum. "In fortress newsroom, readers are something of a necessary inconvenience. We need their business, but not their ideas," writes Steve Smith, editor of Spokane's Spokesman-Review. Smith and other citizen-journalism boosters are fond of repeating the mantra of Dan Gillmor, author of We the Media: Grassroots Journalism by the People, for the People and the director of the Center for Citizen Media: "Our readers know more than we do."

But if the elitist fortress-newsroom mentality held John Q. Public at arm's length, it also kept PR flacks and unqualified hacks out of the newsroom. By forcing their beleaguered staffs to depend on outsiders for content, then running the content without much editorial oversight, newspapers may be taken in by crackpots and sly marketers who make Jayson Blair look like a grade-school plagiarist.

Convergence: The Little Engine that I could give a shit about

“I don’t want to hire single platform journalists anymore.”
That bold statement came from Paul Horrocks, editor of the Manchester Evening News in the UK.

Anyone inspired by a comment like that belongs in accounting, not in journalism. Still, convergence will probably work for the same reason that traffic accidents draw rubberneckers. The new journalism is about reaping the grazers, bored people in their homes or offices who just want a little distraction in their day.

Having reporters put lots of soundbites, photos and and quick links together with a short story will sell for the same reason that McDonald's hamburgers sell. And the content will usually be as healthy for the mind as that fast food is for the body.