Showing posts with label the future. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the future. Show all posts

Jun 23, 2009

Iran dot net

As the political and social consequences of a networked world slowly unfold, Iran has become the test case for how repressive regimes fit into the worldwide web. To that end, the New York Times has a piece today about the "laboratory" that the whole world is watching:

At one time, authoritarian regimes could draw a shroud around the events in their countries by simply snipping the long-distance phone lines and restricting a few foreigners. But this is the new arena of censorship in the 21st century, a world where cellphone cameras, Twitter accounts and all the trappings of the World Wide Web have changed the ancient calculus of how much power governments actually have to sequester their nations from the eyes of the world and make it difficult for their own people to gather, dissent and rebel.

Iran’s sometimes faltering attempts to come to grips with this new reality are providing a laboratory for what can and cannot be done in this new media age — and providing lessons to other governments, watching with calculated interest from afar, about what they may be able to get away with should their own citizens take to the streets.

One early lesson is that it is easier for Iranian authorities to limit images and information within their own country than it is to stop them from spreading rapidly to the outside world. While Iran has severely restricted Internet access, a loose worldwide network of sympathizers has risen up to help keep activists and spontaneous filmmakers connected.

Of course, repressive regimes also monitor these new nodes of communication in hopes of disrupting and punishing dissent.

Meantime, the mainstream media is struggling to adapt to these changes. News outlets have much more information to sift through to determine what they should report - and what they can verify, and must also strike a balance between becoming massive retweeting tools and capturing the larger political and social narratives in their storytelling.

Feb 9, 2009

The children are the future

Few people love journalists - especially other journalists, and most especially publishers who see journalists as mini-black holes from which no profit can escape.

But lots of people love kids - especially their own, and even people without children feel a certain responsibility to make the world a better place for the generations to come.

So, it's perhaps a good thing that the professional journalism preservation crowd has begun to employ a generational appeal when trying to focus minds the Great Newspaper Quandary.

Don't just save journalism for journalists. Do it for the kids.

Walter Isaacson gave the generational-appeal argument a shot in last week's Time magazine to knock down the "information wants to be free" excuse for giving away journalism:
When I used to go fishing in the bayous of Louisiana as a boy, my friend Thomas would sometimes steal ice from those machines outside gas stations. He had the theory that ice should be free. We didn't reflect much on who would make the ice if it were free, but fortunately we grew out of that phase. Likewise, those who believe that all content should be free should reflect on who will open bureaus in Baghdad or be able to fly off as freelancers to report in Rwanda under such a system.

I say this not because I am "evil," which is the description my daughter slings at those who want to charge for their Web content, music or apps. Instead, I say this because my daughter is very creative, and when she gets older, I want her to get paid for producing really neat stuff rather than come to me for money or decide that it makes more sense to be an investment banker.
(As an aside, I'd argue that information is free. I never had to pay for it, save for a few copying costs charged by cheap-ass cities, in all my ten years in print. Yet every story I produced required time, consideration, experience and editing - none of which come for free. Indeed, one could argue that plants want to be free, too, but unless we learn to forage we have to pay farmers for cultivating the lettuce and the corn. If we want to change how the economy compensates people for their work, that's another matter.)

Steven Brill, in a post today on Romenesko, makes a point similar to Isaacson's, although with somebody else's child. Brill endowed a journalism institute at Yale and promises the students who enroll jobs at the end:
The implicit and now-traditional part of the deal is that if you do all this and become a Yale Journalism Scholar, I will also get you a job – which I do, placing them with alumni of The American Lawyer, Court TV and Brills Content (plus Yale alumni) all over the country and world.

The problem is that now I fear I am guiding them off a plank. As one parent put it to me last fall, "why are you luring my daughter into something that will never pay her loans when she could go to work for McKinsey?" I have been trying to construct an answer for her.
Appeals to owners' business sense have hit a wall. Corporate bosses are busy running amok in their mad plan to save newspapers by killing the newspaper business. Those who think they see the cliff ahead are riding herd toward it, hoping resurrection will be found on the rocky ground below.

Appeals to readership have limited success because most people don't know, or really care, how news is produced as long as it's there when they open the front door or turn on the Internet machine. Arguments for newsroom self-preservation fail because they sound arrogant and feed counter-arguments that aging journalists are simply afraid of the new, or are selfishly trying to earn a living, or are jealously guarding bandwidth from roaming hordes of citizen journalists.

Will a focus on the young people who hear the calling have more success? Will owners come to realize they have a responsibility not just to their bottom line but to generations to come?

Maybe, if the appeal echoes in the halls of our top newspapers and news organizations, which have to realize that their future sits in the offices of the crumbling community newspapers around the country.

Oct 15, 2008

On the outside now

My exit from newspapers was nowhere near as dramatic as Steven Smith's resignation from the Spokesman-Review, but I strongly agree with his sense of what we on the perimeter should be concerned about. Asked if there was any place for the old-guard newspapermen in the news world order, Smith said:
It’s absolutely not going to be like it was. It never can be. What I try to emphasize is that the values that are at the core of our calling, the Fourth Estate value, the defending the defenseless value, the telling people what we know when we know it value, holding up and honoring and perpetuating those core values ought now to be our mission.

I'm not out to save newspapers. It may not be possible to save newspapers. But it ought to be possible to save journalism.

Jul 3, 2008

WWJD?

It's Independence Day eve and I'm blue.

I'm putting a show together for Tuesday about the state of the American newspaper. The news is disheartening, and dangerous. Over 1,000 editorial positions slashed in the last week - the latest, and the deepest, at the Los Angeles Times.

All of this because of a revolution.

Thomas Jefferson had a soft spot in his heart for revolutions. The spot he had for newspapers was nearer the spleen. Yet, he still said this:
“Were it left to me to decide whether we should have a government without newspapers or newspapers without a government, I should not hesitate a moment to prefer the latter."
Jefferson, of course, was an elitist. And he didn't have access to the Internet. But I think it's safe to say he had patriotic leanings, and a certain affinity for democracy. To his mind, democracy needed stirring from time to time, a task suited to a free press.

Online publishing is making the physical press obsolete. But the word "press" also represents a collective - reporters and editors banded together to monitor institutions, public and private, that have the power and the means to turn we individuals away, ignore our concerns, resist being stirred. That press is under threat. The culprit, despite the citizen journalist's wish to take credit, is an institution.

The crippled and dying newspapers of today may well provide the ground from which a new crop of publications will spring. Destruction may well be necessary for creation. But this revolution needs revolutionaries, and fewer grave dancers.

Anyway, on to more articulate thoughts on this subject from New York Times columnist Timothy Egan, who does not see a savior in the Huffington Post (HuffPo has its own ideas of "free" and "press"):
Yes, the Brentwood bold-face types who grace HuffPo’s home page can afford to work for free, but it’s un-American, to say the least.

Long ago, I was a member of the steelworkers union, and also a longshoreman. If any of those guys on the docks heard that I was now part of a profession that asked people to labor for nothing, they’d laugh in their lunch buckets — then probably shut The Huffington Post down. Doesn’t the “progressive” agenda, much touted on their pages, include a living wage?

We could be left with a national snark brigade, sniping at the remaining dailies in their pajamas, never rubbing shoulders with a cop, a defense attorney or a distressed family in a Red Cross shelter after a flood.

My lament this Fourth of July is to ask readers to see newspapers as not just another casualty in the churn of business. Sure, reporters say stupid things and write idiotic stories. Everyone stumbles. But on its best days, a newspaper is a marvel of style and wit, of small-type discoveries and large-type overstatements, a diary of our deeds.

We may still prove Jefferson’s preference wrong: perhaps a nation can function without newspapers. But it would be a confederacy of dunces.

Jun 26, 2008

The changing face of AP

I don't know what percentage of stories and photos in small- and medium-size newspapers come from AP and other wire services, but I do know it's substantial. Indeed, many local papers could not put out a daily without the copy provided by wires. And as belt-tightening owners continue to shrink down their own newsrooms, the demand for AP content only grows.

Which is why so many editors are worried about AP's shifting strategy, as outlined in today's Wall Street Journal:

Long a newspaper-centric organization, the AP has shifted its focus in recent years. With readers and advertisers migrating away from news on printed paper and toward cable TV and the Web, the AP is devoting more of its resources to producing content for other news outlets. These include the very Web portals that pose the greatest competition for newspapers, such as Yahoo and Google, which are now among the AP's biggest customers.

Newspapers account for only 27 percent of AP's total revenue, the story says. The big money is in covering Wall Street for Yahoo Finance and the like. And the revenues are being invested in tailoring content to mobile devices.

This doesn't mean AP will stop writing stories, but it isn't as interested in staffing bureaus in places like Ohio or Montana or Arizona. That means less local copy for local papers. In fact, concerned editors in Ohio say AP is becoming more of a taker than a giver.

MediaNews Group CEO Dean Singleton is chairman of the AP board and in the same WSJ story he defended the change in focus:

[Singleton] says that he welcomes a healthy debate about the AP's role in reporting and delivering the news but that the editors' complaints are misguided. "When you're faced with downsizing your news operations and making dramatic changes in how you operate, you always look for someone to blame," he says. "And AP has been a handy entity to complain about."

Singleton knows plenty about being blamed for harming newspapers. But his defense is not simply political. What is AP is doing is consistent with his own strategy, which is to break down the walls of individual newsrooms and to create more of a MediaNews wire service that shares content over a broad region. This gives him leverage to be the "local" provider of quick-hit wire pieces to mobile phones and computers, while the AP focuses more on national niche markets - entertainment, politics, business, etc.